RE: [cobirds] Too bad birders can read...

Birders,

There are many helpful resources out there that address the arrival dates of certain species in CO. Most notable is the eBird Bar Charts tool (http://ebird.org/ebird/GuideMe?cmd=changeLocation). Plug in CO and then select the "Entire Region" button on the right-hand box and press go. The histograms that are presented should lay to waste any doubts that Broad-tailed Hummingbirds are not expected in the state in the last week of March. In fact, it should be revealed that that is exactly when they show up, albeit in low numbers. Scroll down a little and look at when Band-tailed Pigeons occur in the state. Late March is not when the bulk of the pigeons are around, but it's not terribly abnormal (note that they occasionally overwinter in CO). 

And then of course there's the reality that birders make errors. I do not know Gary or Lora Witt, and I am by no means trying to slight them in any way, but their report of an Empid foraging over the Republican River in March instantly makes my skeptical side want to ask, "what made you think it was an Empid rather than an Eastern Phoebe"? One is much more likely. The only Empid that even has a remote chance of being in the state in March is the Gray Flycatcher, and for it to be foraging over a river in the Eastern Plains is unlikely. There is value in understanding the status and distribution of certain species since people have been studying and publishing these trends in books, peer-reviewed articles, etc., for 100+ years. Also, we are often reminded that the human brain is fallible. An error is more likely, in this case, then an undocumented hypothetical record. 

This natural skepticism was, I'm sure, applied to Paula's Ash-throated Flycatcher report. This is not a personal slight, but just the nature of the beast. Any report of a heard-only Myiarchus flycatcher in March on the northern Front Range will get a raised eyebrow from me, and probably most other people in the birding community. This is why reports of such magnitude require documentation. I don't know what kind of electronics Paula is lugging around in the field, but if it's a smart phone, then it's very easy to use the video function to record bird sounds. I use an iPhone and it's surprisingly capable of recording sounds if the bird is at a reasonable distance. Of course, if her bird only called a few times and then was silent, there may not have been time to record it. Given this result, it was very appropriate for her to get the word out so that others could try to get on the bird, whatever it was.  

Tact is required by both the observer of a vagrant bird and by those who are willing to communicate their skepticism. I do hope that I'm utilizing it here successfully. 

Christian Nunes

Boulder, CO 

---

Date: Mon, 31 Mar 2014 09:23:15 -0600
Subject: [cobirds] Too bad birders can read...
From: redstart.paula@gmail.com
To: cobirds@googlegroups.com
CC: redstart.paula@gmail.com

The Empid seen over the weekend in NE Colo., my possible flycatcher heard last week, Bill Kaempfer's Band-tailed Pigeon of a couple of weeks ago, and Jeff Jones' recent hummer are all examples of early migrants.   (and probably many other birds that are dismissed because "they aren't supposed to be here yet")

Because they take field guides too literally, many birders commonly dismiss "out-of-season" bird reports and totally ignore even what they see or hear.

Birds can fly and take advantage of favorable winds and other weather conditions...and, because they cannot read books that say they should not be at a certain latitude before a particular date, they can easily appear "early" if weather is favorable!

Paula Hansley

Louisville

--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Colorado Birds" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to cobirds+unsubscribe@googlegroups.com.
To post to this group, send email to cobirds@googlegroups.com.
To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/cobirds/CANF-7hocwU0Mita3Tu08BURT5U1L2eeHAdGyiMqwzt2SNm3GKQ%40mail.gmail.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.